Best Chainsaws: Gas vs. Electric

There’s a symphony to the homestead, isn't there? The cheerful cluck of chickens, the distant bleat of a goat, and, for many of us, the distinct roar or confident hum of a chainsaw. Whether you're felling a tree, bucking up firewood, clearing storm debris, or milling lumber for a new project, a chainsaw is an indispensable tool for any serious homesteader. It’s a powerful extension of your will, transforming unruly timber into manageable resources. But step into any hardware store or browse online, and you're immediately confronted with a fundamental choice: do you unleash the raw, unbridled might of a gas-powered chainsaw, or do you embrace the quiet, convenient revolution of an electric model?

This isn't just about fuel type; it's about a fundamental difference in how these machines deliver power, how easily they can be transported and maneuvered, and the ongoing effort you'll invest in keeping them running. As someone who’s spent three decades immersed in homesteading supplies, from the robust Stihls of the logging crew to the nimble battery-powered units for backyard cleanup, I’ve seen these saws chew through countless cords of wood, understood their nuances, and heard every triumph and frustration imaginable. So, let’s rev up our knowledge and dive deep into the fascinating world of chainsaws, dissecting the critical aspects of power, portability, and maintenance, all while unearthing some fantastic product recommendations to help you make the cut for your homestead.

The Heart of the Beast:
Understanding Chainsaw Power

At its core, a chainsaw is a motorized saw that drives a continuous chain with sharp teeth around a guide bar. The engine or motor generates the power, which is then transferred to the chain, allowing it to cut through wood. The key performance indicators are:

• Engine Displacement (Gas): Measured in cubic centimeters (cc), indicating the size of the engine. Larger displacement generally means more power.

• Voltage (Electric): Measured in volts (V) for battery-powered or amps (A) for corded. Higher voltage/amperage usually means more power.

• Bar Length: The length of the guide bar, typically measured in inches. This dictates the maximum diameter of wood you can cut in a single pass.

• Chain Speed: How fast the chain moves around the bar, impacting cutting speed.
  
  

The type of power source—gas or electric—fundamentally dictates how these metrics translate into real-world performance.

Gas Chainsaws:
The Roaring Workhorse

Gas chainsaws are the traditional choice for heavy-duty cutting. They are powered by two-stroke internal combustion engines that run on a mix of gasoline and two-stroke oil. They are synonymous with raw power and sustained performance.

Power: This is the undisputed domain of gas chainsaws. They offer superior power and torque compared to most electric models, especially when tackling large-diameter trees, dense hardwoods, or extensive cutting tasks. Their engines can run continuously as long as they have fuel, making them ideal for long days in the woods, felling large trees, or bucking up entire cordwood piles. When you need to power through thick logs without bogging down, a gas saw is usually the go-to choice. They can handle longer guide bars, allowing them to cut wider logs in a single pass.

Portability: While "portable" in the sense that they're not tethered by a cord, gas chainsaws are generally heavier and bulkier than electric models. They require fuel and oil, which adds to the logistical burden. You also need to consider hearing protection, fuel cans, and proper ventilation for fumes. For remote work, you can just bring extra fuel, but their weight can be a factor during extended periods of use, especially for smaller users.

Maintenance: This is where gas chainsaws demand more from their owners. They require regular maintenance, much like any small engine. This includes mixing fuel, cleaning air filters, replacing spark plugs, sharpening chains frequently, adjusting carburetor settings, and checking fluid levels (chain oil). They can be finicky to start, especially after sitting for a while, often requiring multiple pulls of a starter cord. Winterizing and de-winterizing are also considerations. Their complexity means more potential points of failure and generally a higher learning curve for basic repairs.

Pros of Gas Chainsaws:

• Superior Power: Best for large trees, dense wood, and heavy-duty cutting.

• Unlimited Runtime: Runs as long as you have fuel, ideal for extended work.

• No Power Cord/Battery Issues: True untethered freedom in remote locations.

• Wider Range of Bar Lengths: Can handle very long guide bars for large diameter cuts.
  
  
  

Cons of Gas Chainsaws:

• Heavier & Bulkier: More fatiguing for prolonged use; less nimble.

• Higher Maintenance: Requires regular engine care, fuel mixing, and more frequent servicing.

• Noise & Emissions: Very loud and produce exhaust fumes; require hearing protection and ventilation.

• Starting Issues: Can be difficult to start, especially when cold or after storage.

• Fuel Storage: Requires safe storage of gasoline/oil mixture.

Electric Chainsaws:
The Quiet Revolution

Electric chainsaws come in two main varieties: corded (plug-in) and battery-powered (cordless). Both eliminate the need for gasoline and engine maintenance, bringing a new level of convenience and user-friendliness to the cutting task.

Power: Electric chainsaws have made significant strides in power, with high-voltage battery models now rivaling smaller to mid-sized gas saws. Corded electric chainsaws offer consistent power as long as they are plugged in, but their range is limited by the extension cord. Battery-powered electric chainsaws offer cordless freedom, but their runtime is limited by battery capacity, and power can diminish as the battery drains. While they might not fell a giant oak as quickly as a large gas saw, they are remarkably capable for limbing, bucking smaller logs (up to 18-20 inches), and clearing storm debris. Their instant torque often makes them feel surprisingly powerful on the first cut.

Portability: This is where electric chainsaws truly shine. Battery-powered models offer unparalleled portability and freedom of movement without the weight of an engine or the hassle of a cord. They are lighter than gas saws, making them less fatiguing and easier to maneuver, especially for overhead work or in tight spaces. Corded electric saws are also lighter than gas, but their portability is constrained by the need for an electrical outlet and a suitable extension cord. Both types eliminate the need for carrying fuel or dealing with fumes.

Maintenance: Electric chainsaws are a dream for low maintenance. There's no engine to service, no spark plugs to change, and no fuel to mix. You simply keep the chain sharpened (which all chainsaws require), ensure the bar is properly oiled (most have automatic oilers), and keep the air vents clean. Battery models just need charging. This simplicity makes them incredibly appealing for casual users, or for homesteaders who want a reliable saw that's always ready to go without fuss.

Pros of Electric Chainsaws:

• Low Maintenance: No engine maintenance, fuel mixing, or tricky starts.

• Quiet Operation: Much quieter than gas saws; some are almost silent.

• No Emissions: Environmentally friendlier; can be used indoors (e.g., in a workshop for milling).

• Instant Start: No pull cord; just press a button or pull a trigger.

• Lighter Weight: Less fatigue, easier to maneuver.

• Cleanliness: No spilled gas or exhaust residue.
  
  
  

Cons of Electric Chainsaws:

• Limited Runtime (Battery): Battery life dictates how long you can cut; requires multiple batteries for extended work.

• Power Limit (Corded): Restricted by extension cord length and available outlets.

• Less Overall Power: May bog down on very large or dense wood compared to high-end gas saws.

• Battery Cost: Batteries and chargers add to the initial investment for cordless models.

• Cold Weather Performance (Battery): Battery performance can be reduced in very cold temperatures.

The Cutting-Edge Decision:
Gas or Electric for Your Homestead?

The ultimate choice between a gas and electric chainsaw hinges on your primary cutting needs, the types of wood you'll encounter, and your comfort level with maintenance:

• Choose a Gas Chainsaw if: You regularly fell large trees, process entire cords of dense firewood, need maximum power and torque for heavy-duty, continuous work, or operate in remote areas far from power outlets. You are comfortable with engine maintenance and noise.
  
  

• Choose an Electric Chainsaw (Battery) if: You primarily do limbing, bucking smaller logs (up to 18-20 inches), clearing storm debris, or occasional firewood. You prioritize ease of use, low maintenance, quiet operation, and portability. You have access to charging and don't need extended, continuous runtimes.
  
  

• Choose an Electric Chainsaw (Corded) if: You primarily work close to an outdoor power outlet (e.g., around the house, in a workshop), cut smaller logs, and want low maintenance and quiet operation without battery limitations.
  
  
  

Many homesteaders find that owning both provides the best of all worlds: a powerful gas saw for heavy jobs and a nimble battery-powered electric saw for quick tasks, limbing, or situations where noise and fumes are a concern. It's about building a cutting arsenal that matches the diverse demands of homestead life.

Now, let's explore some real-world products that I've personally seen perform exceptionally well, helping homesteaders tackle their wood processing tasks with confidence and efficiency.

Product Reviews:
My Top Picks for Chainsaws

Having stocked, used, and recommended countless chainsaws for various homesteading and professional applications over the decades, these seven products consistently stand out for their quality, performance, power, portability, and maintenance profiles, meeting a range of needs and budgets.

Clicking any of the following link's may result in a
small commission for our family farm.

STIHL MS 271 Farm Boss Chainsaw (Gas)

Price Range: $400 - $500 (powerhead only, bar and chain usually included).

Description: The STIHL MS 271 Farm Boss is a legendary gas-powered chainsaw, revered by homesteaders and professional loggers alike for its robust performance and reliability. It features a powerful 50.2 cc engine, typically paired with a 16-inch or 18-inch guide bar. Designed for demanding farm and ranch tasks, it offers excellent power-to-weight ratio, an anti-vibration system, and an easy-access air filter.

Why I love it: This saw is the epitome of a hard-working, dependable gas chainsaw. It has more than enough power to fell medium-sized trees, buck large logs, and handle extensive firewood cutting without bogging down. Its durability is outstanding, built to withstand years of heavy use. While it requires traditional gas saw maintenance, its reliability and consistent power make it an indispensable tool for any serious homesteader who needs a workhorse saw. It starts reliably and powers through tough jobs.

Milwaukee M18 FUEL 16" Chainsaw (Battery Electric)

Price Range: $300 - $400 (tool only, batteries and charger separate). A kit with batteries and charger might be $500-$700.

Description: The Milwaukee M18 FUEL 16" Chainsaw is a powerful battery-electric saw that runs on Milwaukee's M18 REDLITHIUM batteries. It's designed to deliver the power and cutting speed comparable to a 40cc gas chainsaw, but with the convenience of battery power. It features instant throttle response, no gas or oil mixing, and much quieter operation.

Why I love it: For homesteaders already invested in Milwaukee's M18 battery platform, this saw is a no-brainer. It delivers surprising power for a battery saw, easily handling limbing, bucking 12-16 inch logs, and clearing storm debris. The instant start, quiet operation, and zero emissions are huge advantages for quick tasks or working near the house. It's incredibly low maintenance and perfect for anyone who wants gas-like power without the gas hassle.

Greenworks 80V 18-inch Brushless Chainsaw (Battery Electric)

Price Range: $250 - $400 (often as a kit with battery and charger).

Description: The Greenworks 80V 18-inch Brushless Chainsaw is a high-voltage battery-electric saw designed for heavy-duty cutting. It features an efficient brushless motor that provides gas-like power for felling medium trees and bucking large logs. It offers instant starts, quiet operation, and minimal maintenance. Often comes as a kit with a battery and charger.

Why I love it: Greenworks has become a leader in powerful battery outdoor equipment, and their 80V chainsaw is a testament to that. This saw delivers serious cutting power that will impress even gas-saw loyalists, making it a viable alternative for many homesteading tasks. The longer 18-inch bar expands its capabilities, and the 80V platform provides ample runtime for typical tasks. It’s a fantastic choice for those fully embracing electric outdoor power.

Husqvarna 455 Rancher Chainsaw (Gas)

Price Range: $450 - $550 (powerhead only, bar and chain usually included).

Description: The Husqvarna 455 Rancher is another highly popular and respected gas-powered chainsaw, often considered a direct competitor to the STIHL Farm Boss. It features a powerful 55.5 cc X-Torq engine designed for fuel efficiency and reduced emissions, typically with an 18-inch or 20-inch bar. It's known for its robust build, ease of starting, and ergonomic design for comfortable, prolonged use.

Why I love it: The 455 Rancher is a true workhorse for medium to heavy-duty homesteading tasks. It offers excellent power and durability, making quick work of felling and bucking. Its X-Torq engine is a plus for fuel economy and emissions. It's a reliable, powerful saw that can tackle significant projects, and its ergonomic design helps reduce fatigue during long cutting sessions.

DEWALT 20V MAX XR Chainsaw DCCS620B (Battery Electric - Compact)

Price Range: $150 - $250 (tool only, batteries and charger separate). A kit might be $250-$400.

Description: The DEWALT 20V MAX XR Chainsaw is a more compact and lightweight battery-electric saw, often paired with a 12-inch or 14-inch bar. It runs on DEWALT's popular 20V MAX battery platform. It's designed for quick, light-duty cutting tasks like limbing, pruning, and small bucking jobs, offering the convenience of instant starts and low noise.

Why I love it: For quick, everyday homesteading tasks, this DEWALT saw is fantastic. It's incredibly light and nimble, making it perfect for limbing up branches, clearing brush, or doing small cleanup jobs where a larger saw would be overkill. If you're already on the DEWALT 20V system, it's an easy and valuable addition. It's a go-to for grab-and-go convenience and comfortable use.

Oregon CS1500 Self-Sharpening Electric Chainsaw (Corded Electric)

Price Range: $100 - $150.

Description: The Oregon CS1500 is a powerful corded electric chainsaw, typically with an 18-inch bar. Its standout feature is its integrated PowerSharp sharpening system, which allows you to sharpen the chain on the saw in a matter of seconds by simply pulling a lever. It offers instant starts, constant corded power, and low noise.

Why I love it: For homesteaders who work primarily near a power source (e.g., bucking firewood by the woodshed, clearing around the house), this saw is incredibly convenient. The self-sharpening feature is a game-changer, eliminating the frustration of dull chains and saving significant time. It delivers consistent power without battery limitations, and its low noise and lack of fumes make it very pleasant to operate. It's ideal for steady, non-remote cutting.

Makita XCU03PT1 18V X2 (36V) LXT Brushless Cordless Chainsaw Kit (Battery Electric)

Price Range: $350 - $500 (kit with batteries and charger).

Description: The Makita XCU03PT1 is a professional-grade battery-electric chainsaw that uses two 18V Makita batteries (for a total of 36V) to deliver power comparable to a 32cc gas chainsaw. It features a powerful brushless motor, a 14-inch or 16-inch bar, and a variable speed trigger. It's known for its efficiency, low noise, and robust build quality.

Why I love it: Makita has engineered this saw for serious work without the gas. By using two 18V batteries, it achieves significant power and runtime, making it capable of handling substantial cutting tasks for a battery saw. It's incredibly well-balanced, quiet, and delivers smooth, efficient cuts. For homesteaders who appreciate professional-grade tools and are already invested in Makita's extensive LXT battery platform, this saw is a top-tier choice for heavy-duty electric cutting.

Making the Cut:
Your Homestead's Chainsaw Choice

The chainsaw, in either its gas or electric form, is a transformative tool for any homesteader. It empowers you to manage your woodlot, clear your land, and secure your fuel supply with efficiency and muscle. The choice between gas and electric isn't about one being inherently "better," but rather which aligns most perfectly with your specific needs, the scale of your tasks, and your preference for power versus convenience.

Whether you hear the satisfying roar of a gas engine or the confident hum of an electric motor, remember that safety is paramount. Always wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE), understand your saw's capabilities, and practice proper cutting techniques. With the right chainsaw in hand, you're not just cutting wood; you're cultivating self-reliance and shaping the very landscape of your homesteading dreams. Happy cutting!